Breaking News
SCRANTON — Testifying for the prosecution in the homicide trial of Justin Schuback, cq Maria Baron repeatedly told the jury she didn't believe her son Robert Baron, Jr. was involved in the death of his father, Robert Baron, Sr.
But when defense attorney Bernie Brown asked Maria Baron if, as a witness for the prosecution of Justin Schuback, she was sure her son didn't have anything to do with the 2017 death of her husband, Baron waffled.
"I hope to God it's not true," she said.
But, Brown may have lost some ground with the jury when, just after asking Baron if she suspected her son knew more than he was saying and if she had said so in a podcast, he directed his assistant to play an excerpt.
Instead of Maria Baron's voice, jurors heard another voice alleging Robert Baron had been heavily involved in gambling.
Judge Thomas Nealon immediately cleared jurors from the courtroom. He told Brown a basic requirement for using technology in his courtroom is knowing how to use it.
"This is a serious admonition," Nealon told Brown, who immediately apologized.
Nealon asked Brown if he knew which "Robert Baron" the podcaster was referring to. Brown said he believed it was Baron Sr.
When jurors reentered the courtroom, Nealon told them to disregard the part of the podcast they heard earlier.
He said of technology, "It can be disastrous when it doesn't work."
During direct questioning by District Attorney Mark Powell, Maria Baron described her relationship with her husband as being "very good."
Baron said, even though the couple had been separated for six years and Baron, Sr. lived above his restaurant, the two saw each other nearly everyday and often went out to dinner and attended events with their three adult children, including Baron, Jr.
She said Baron, Jr. would help out at the restaurant about four times a week, often meeting his father in the morning to prepare for a 4 p.m. opening.
She said, because the business was "cash only," Robert Baron, Sr. often kept money on him and kept money at the shop.
Maria Baron said when she worked at the restaurant and needed more cash to make change for a customer, she would simply ask Baron, Sr.
The evening of Baron's disappearance, the two had eaten tacos together, she said.
At about 10 p.m., Baron, Sr. headed back to the restaurant with tacos for Baron, Jr. who was on shift.
She said when Baron, Sr. left her house the night of his disappearance, he had cash on him.
"It was sticking out of his pocket and I told him to put it back in," she said.
When Brown cross-examined Maria Baron, however, she admitted her husband had been preoccupied with Baron, Jr.'s addiction.
Baron said she believed her son was using drugs at the time of her husband's disappearance, because of some of the people he was spending time with.
"I felt he was," she said.
When Brown asked Maria Baron if Baron Jr. had even stolen, she responded, "He has taken money."
When asked who had keys to the building, Maria Baron said only Baron, Sr., Baron, Jr. and Mark Baron, her brother-in-law had keys to the building.
If Maria Baron needed access to the restaurant and her husband wasn't going to be there, she borrowed a key, she said.
Testimony opened Tuesday morning, with prosecution witnesses detailing evidence against Schuback.
During questioning by Assistant District Attorney Sara Varela, Old Forge police officer Dave Kimble told the jury Maria Baron came to the police department at about 10:30 a.m. on Jan. 26 to report her husband Robert Baron Sr. missing.
Kimble said he immediately responded to Ghigiarelli’s Restaurant, the pizzeria Baron owned and where he was last seen.
Originally, he said, nothing seemed out of place. But, soon he spotted blood in areas around the restaurant and alerted Police Chief Jason Dubernas.
"There was something more," he said.
The Old Forge police department soon sought the assistance of Taylor Police and state police crime scene investigators.
The prosecution alleges a conspicuous amount of blood found at the restaurant was the result of a fight between Schuback and Baron Sr., which ended in Baron's death.
But on cross examination, defense attorney Bernie Brown asked Kimble if, before coming to the police station, Maria and her son Robert Baron Jr. had been to the restaurant. Kimble said he assumed they first went to the restaurant to see if Baron Sr. was there.
Brown asked Kimble if he remembered Baron Jr. saying, "If my dad's dead, I'm going back on drugs." Kimble said he did not.
During Monday's opening statement, Brown asked the jury to consider other suspects in the brutal death, including Robert, Jr., who he said, was "in a mood" and about to be cut off by his father financially, because of his drug habit.
Brown asked Kimble if anything inside the restaurant indicated Schuback had been inside the eatery.
"Not that I'm aware," Kimble responded.
Varela opened the prosecution's case by introducing a series of photos documenting blood, hair and other evidence which law enforcement gathered after Robert Baron Sr. went missing on Jan. 25, 2017.
Police originally questioned Schuback and others. They also searched Pagnotti Park, near Schuback's home on Foundry Street.
But, in spite of continued investigation, police did not find Baron's body or make an arrest until March 2023 when Special Agent Michael Sabric of the FBI Cellular Analysis Team analyzed Schuback’s cellphone by using data collected in 2017.
The data put Schuback at the restaurant just before midnight on Jan. 25, 2017, before travelling to a specific area of Pagnotti Park, to his Foundry Street residence and then to the 100 block of Howard Street where Baron's Hyundai Elantra was found days later.
Police say the cell phone analysis led them Baron's remains in a specific area of Pagnotti Park.
On March 31, officers arrested Schuback at gunpoint. He was jailed at Lackawanna County Prison without bail.
Schuback could spend life in prison if convicted of several murder charges. Read moreTestimony begins in Schuback trial 💬
SCRANTON — Lois Flamholz’s story of struggles during the Holocaust struck a chord with students Tuesday morning. Read moreHolocaust survivors share stories with students 💬
Facing possible imminent closure and loss of accreditation, Keystone College must prepare by May 15 an updated plan for potentially closing an… Read moreKeystone College accreditor requires more information on continuing or closing 💬
The Scranton Housing Authority plans to use nearly $4 million in federal funding for improvements at its Valley View Terrace and Hilltop Manor… Read moreLocal housing authorities will use federal HUD funds for capital improvements 💬
The city revoked a notice of apparent zoning violation it issued in March over the brightness of the downtown Scranton Art Haus Cinema and Soc… Read more'Amicable resolution:' City revoked violation notice issued over movie theater marquee 💬
A group of students from Abington Heights High School earned top honors in the nation for their acumen in the courtroom. Read moreAHHS mock trial team wins national championship 💬
SCRANTON — A Throop police officer who is also a county prison guard twice swapped out used footwear for new sneakers at Dick’s Sporting Goods… Read morePolice: Officer stole sneakers from Dick's 💬
Lackawanna County commissioners acting in their capacity as members of the county election board certified Tuesday the results of last month’s… Read moreLackawanna County election board certifies April 23 primary results 💬
A Scranton woman faces animal cruelty and neglect charges after police recovered 10 cats from a feces-strewn shed and others from an Archbald … Read moreScranton police charge woman with animal cruelty, neglect 💬
JENKINS TWP. — A woman stabbed a man in the back early Monday at a township mobile home park, investigators allege. Read morePolice: Woman stabs man in Jenkins Twp. mobile home early Monday 💬
SCRANTON — From longtime customers like Beth McDonald Zangardi of Dunmore to first-time shopper Joan Perna of Lakeville, Glint of Gold had a c… Read moreGlint of Gold closing after four decades in Scranton 💬
WILKES-BARRE — With sound checks being done on stage for a sold-out rock concert Monday night, the leader of the F.M. Kirby Center took media … Read moreKirby Center officials reveal $4 million in flooding damage as sold-out shows continue 💬
SCRANTON — Prosecutors described a man accused of killing Old Forge restaurateur Robert Baron Sr. in 2017 as “desperate for dope,” in their op… Read moreSchuback trial underway in killing of Old Forge restaurateur 💬
Housing authorities in Lackawanna, Luzerne and Monroe counties will together benefit from more than $17 million in federal funding for capital… Read moreNEPA housing authorities to benefit from more than $17 million in federal funding 💬
A Luzerne County judge has sentenced a disbarred attorney who had worked for a prominent Scranton law firm to 30 days in jail on forgery and r… Read moreLuzerne County judge gives disbarred lawyer 30 days in prison 💬
The Latest
Most Recent Blogs
- Review: "The Fall Guy"
- A cancer that can be prevented by vaccination
- HS TRACK AND FIELD: Phil Tochelli Junior High Championship Meet (GIRLS RESULTS)
- HS TRACK AND FIELD: Phil Tochelli Junior High Championship Meet (BOYS RESULTS)
- Timing, as much as anything, lends to end of Montgomery's Penn State run
- PENN STATED: On Draft...A breakdown of the newest Nittany Lions in the NFL
- HS TRACK AND FIELD: Lackawanna Track Conference Championship History
- Monroe County's Top 50 employers
- Susquehanna County's Top 50 Employers
- Wyoming County's Top 50 Employers
- Wayne County's Top 50 employers
- Pike County's Top 50 Employers
- Healthy competition provides jobs, livelihood to thousands in NEPA
- Luzerne County's Top 50 Employers
- A pipeline of talent continues to emerge in Northeast Pennsylvania
- Education of tomorrow requires flexibility, empathy
- Dreaming of rail service to NYC: Proposed train promises economic benefits, advocates say
Recent News
Most Popular
-
Police: Officer stole sneakers from Dick's
-
Glint of Gold closing after four decades in Scranton
-
Schuback trial underway in killing of Old Forge restaurateur
-
Keystone College accreditor requires more information on continuing or closing
-
Luzerne County judge gives disbarred lawyer 30 days in prison
-
'Amicable resolution:' City revoked violation notice issued over movie theater marquee
-
Lackawanna County Court Notes 5/7/24
-
AHHS mock trial team wins national championship
-
Archbald native Black makes MLB debut against Phillies
-
Kirby Center officials reveal $4 million in flooding damage as sold-out shows continue
This Week's Most Popular Blog Posts
Viral News
- Sideways day on Wall Street as London notches another record
- Europe student Gaza protests spread, sparking clashes, arrests
- Pajamas, 'honeybunch' and sex: Stormy testifies
- CFL suspends Argos QB Chad Kelly for at least 9 games
- China's Xi lands in Serbia after talking Ukraine, trade in France
- Braves place LHP Tyler Matzek (elbow) on 15-day injured list
Pitching prospect Mason Black made his major league debut for the San Francisco Giants against the Philadelphia Phillies on Monday. The Giants… 💬
JERUSALEM — Hamas announced its acceptance Monday of an Egyptian-Qatari cease-fire proposal, but Israel said the deal did not meet its “core d… 💬
NEW YORK — Columbia University canceled its large universitywide commencement ceremony Monday following weeks of pro-Palestinian protests that… 💬
Michael Glabicki and the Rusted Root Uprooted Trio will perform a free show at 7:30 p.m. May 18 on Public Square as part of the Fine Arts Fiesta. 💬
For the first time, researchers have identified a genetic form of late-in-life Alzheimer's disease. Most cases of the mind-robbing disease occ… 💬
HARRISBURG — The two-engine, eight-seat Beechcraft King Air 350i took off from a small regional airport across the Susquehanna River from Penn… 💬
One of the greatest frustrations in modern medicine occurs when a safe, tried and proven treatment exists to prevent deadly disease, but it is… 💬
May 5—Whether you're watching the Phillies, the Texas Rangers, or the Seattle Mariners, the baseballs belted over the centerfield wall were li… 💬
- Stormy Daniels describes meeting Trump during occasionally graphic testimony in hush money trial
- The Latest | Stormy Daniels to return to witness stand on Thursday as court adjourns
- Some colleges that had been permissive of pro-Palestinian protests begin taking a tougher stance
- Boy Scouts of America changing name to more inclusive Scouting America after years of woes
State News
- Which states could have abortion on the ballot in 2024?
- Money isn't enough to smooth the path for Republican candidates hoping to retake the Senate
- One natural gas transport plan killed in New Jersey as another forges ahead
- A man tried to shoot a pastor during a church service but his gun wouldn't fire, state police say
- Senate races are roiled by campus protests over the war in Gaza as campaign rhetoric sharpens
Strange News
- Australian woman denies murdering her former husband's relatives with poisonous mushroom lunch
- Escaped zebra captured near Seattle after gallivanting around Cascade mountain foothills for days
- Snakes almost on a plane: TSA discovers a bag with small snakes in passenger's pants
- The Twins and their lucky home run sausage are home safely with the winning streak still intact
- Man says his emotional support alligator, known for its big social media audience, has gone missing
- Utah cat with a fondness for cardboard takes surprise trip to California in an Amazon box
PHILADELPHIA — Mason Black and his younger brother woke up the morning of Oct. 7, 2011 and were surprised to find Phillies tickets for a playo… Read moreArchbald native Black makes MLB debut against Phillies 💬
The Lady Devils senior softball player compiled 38 strikeouts, including the 800th of her career, while allowing just one run, five hits and f… Read moreATHLETE OF THE WEEK: Old Forge's Karen Sickle 💬
Lehigh Valley Health Network - Coordinated Health, Official Sports Medicine Sponsors of the Athlete of the Week 💬
On the biggest day of one former Valley View star’s professional career, another is going through a disappointment. Read moreN.Y. Mets DFA Valley View graduate Kranick 💬
Nick Bohenek tossed a five-inning no-hitter as Riverside defeated Lakeland, 10-0, in a Lackawanna League Division II baseball game Monday at R… Read moreMONDAY'S HS BASEBALL ROUNDUP: Riverside's Bohenek tosses five-inning no-hitter 💬
Krista Cortazar hit a two-run home run to tie the game in the bottom of the sixth and Chiara Zavislak hit a triple to score Audrey Hasenzahl w… Read moreMONDAY'S SOFTBALL ROUNDUP: Cortazar, Zavislak spark Spartanettes 💬
WILKES-BARRE — Joshua Rocha flew toward a Jack Wasiakowski set as two Blue Ridge defenders went for the block. Read moreMONDAY'S HS ROUNDUP: Blue Ridge suffers first setback in loss to Holy Redeemer in volleyball 💬
Just after the last of the runners crossed the finish line, a couple of Mid Valley sprinters darted around the tent, took a glance at the scor… Read moreHS TRACK AND FIELD: Mid Valley girls look to carry momentum into Spagna Championship meet 💬
The RailRiders compiled a season-high 14 hits while allowing no hits until the eighth inning, as Scranton/Wilkes-Barre completed a six-game sw… Read moreRailRiders sweep Jumbo Shrimp 💬
For Mason Black, the time is almost here. Read moreBlack to make MLB debut Monday in Philadelphia 💬
Support local news you can trust. We depend on the support of our loyal subscribers to produce meaningful journalism every day. Help us continue this important work: subscribe today.
Ever wonder why election results from Florida are typically available just hours after the polls close on Election Day while in Pennsylvania, … Read moreState Senate should support pre-canvassing bill 💬
There is no artificial intelligence without the vast trove of human knowledge. Read moreArtificial Intelligence not possible without wealth of human knowledge 💬
Like a stubborn sapling obscured in a forest of thorns, kindness struggles for sunlight in the wicked garden we’ve made. Read moreChris Kelly Opinion: In a cruel time, these twins are 'courageously kind' 💬
“Jimmie” Howard was 8 years old when he began sharing his love of pencils with the world outside Scranton. Read moreChris Kelly Opinion: A boy, his pencils and history's keepers 💬
Households at all income levels are impacted by Pennsylvania’s housing crisis. For affordable housing —where the resident pays no more than 30… 💬
Greg Ip, economics commentator for the Wall Street Journal, has made an interesting and relevant observation about the American economy. Accor… 💬
Columnists
- Commonwealth investment helps close NEPA's affordable housing gap
- A replicable path to prosperity 'RISEs' up in the Electric City
- Chris Kelly Opinion: In a cruel time, these twins are 'courageously kind'
- Government officials are ill-equipped to make business decisions
- Chris Kelly Opinion: 'Goliath' vs. Hamas in Gaza
- The world is a better place with Pennsylvania energy
- Chris Kelly Opinion: Landfills burying our brand
- Chris Kelly Opinion: Eclipse a welcome distraction from toxic orange blob
- Failure to ratify Treaty of the Seas risks economic and environmental consequences
- Chris Kelly Opinion: Scranton Joe surges, MAGA cons shrink
John Cole Cartoons
Falling in Reverse is running back its 2023 Popular MonsTOUR, and this time it will come through Scranton. Read moreFalling in Reverse bringing Popular MonsTOUR II to Montage 💬